A few months ago, I joined a book club. A women’s business group—business-y non-fiction books. My first night, eight of us were sitting in a circle, and I was the new one.
We settled in, waited on the stragglers, made the easy small talk you make before a thing starts. Then the organizer smiled and said it: “Let’s go around and introduce ourselves with our elevator pitch.”
A book club. And we were pitching. Some of the women were ready. You could tell. The words were smooth and effortless. The whole thing had clearly been rehearsed, maybe in the car on the way over.
Then there was me, the newcomer and the quiet one, silently sweating my own pitch for the 100th time and deciding I would keep it short and safe.
Mid-50s, and this kinda crap still terrifies me. Here’s why I lacked preparation: It wasn’t even a sales event; it was a book club.
The conference reception. The workshop kickoff. The go-around at the top of the meeting. Default mode is, “Tell us who you are and what you do,” delivered cold, on command.
That format fails almost everyone. Not just the quiet ones—the confident stumble, too. I have watched genuinely polished people trip over, “So, what do you do,” because selling yourself in one breath, to strangers, before you have settled into the room is a hard thing to do well.
So, if it rattles nearly everyone, why do we keep opening with it?
The stumble costs some people more than others
The confident one stumbles, laughs, keeps talking. The recovery is public and cheap. The quieter one stumbles and reads it as evidence that they are bad at this, that they don’t quite belong, that the safe move is to stay small for the rest of the event. And they do.
You don’t lose an awkward 30 seconds from them. You lose them for the whole thing.
Picture who that usually is—not the extroverted salesperson hunting for leads, but the quietly brilliant ones who think before speaking, whose single comment two hours later would have been the most useful thing said all night. Your opening talked them out of it in the first five minutes.
Providing an “opportunity to speak” is not equivalent to good design
Here is the pushback I expect: “The go-around is inclusive. Everyone gets a turn. It keeps the loudest voice from running the table.”
Fair. But a turn and a safety net are not the same thing.
The round-robin pitch hands everyone the floor, then demands a performance to hold it. It rewards whoever packages themselves the fastest, not whoever has the best idea.
What we actually want from these people is contribution. An insight. A reaction. A build on someone else’s point. Instead, we ask for a polished commercial, cold, then wonder why the room feels stiff.
Structure isn’t the same as safety. You can give everyone a slot and still design most of them into silence.
Design for contribution, not performance
The fix is not coaching the quiet people to pitch better. That puts the work on the wrong person. It belongs to us, the ones building the room.
Lower the ask. Trade “tell us what you do” for a question people can actually answer: “What surprised you this year?” “What are you wrestling with?” or “What has you most excited this season?”
Let them jot a thought first or trade it with one neighbor before the group. Give them something to contribute instead of something to sell.
You spent real money to get these minds in one room. Design the opening so you can actually hear them because the best idea at the table is often sitting with the person you just asked to uncomfortably go first.


